Option A: Claude: one chat builds the workbook
Best when: One tool, one draft file, mapping confirmed midway
What it does: Claude builds; you confirm mapping and totals
Strong at: Mapping owned by you before totals are built
Limit: Assistant picks source cells; sample-check the traces
Free plan: Yes
Option B: Gemini: a live spreadsheet you can inspect
Best when: A working spreadsheet, not a generated file
What it does: Gemini merges in-sheet; you confirm the result
Strong at: Every step inspectable in the spreadsheet
Limit: Gemini samples rows; full-table results need checks
Free plan: Yes
Option C: ChatGPT: labels only; formulas run in your sheet
Best when: Mapping confirmed before any amounts are merged
What it does: ChatGPT writes formulas; amounts stay in-house
Strong at: Only labels and layouts leave your spreadsheets
Limit: You apply the formula plan by hand
Free plan: Yes, limited (uploads and analysis capped)